• Home
  • News
  • Global Shippers Forum points out the lack of competition in container shipping
  • 2022 June 29 09:35

    Global Shippers Forum points out the lack of competition in container shipping

    Current measures of competitiveness in the global liner shipping market are incomplete and therefore inaccurate and fail to take full account of the degree of co-operation between carriers which results in a more highly concentrated industry, to the serious detriment of shippers worldwide, according to the Global Shippers Forum's release.

    This conclusion is one of the findings presented in the Container Shipping Market Quarterly Review for Quarter 1 2022 prepared by MDS Transmodal (MDST) in collaboration with Global Shippers Forum (GSF). A modified measure is proposed, based on the alternative indicators suggested in a recent study produced by OECD/ITF and MDST that better reflects the degree of cooperation by lines, not just through the three big alliances but also agreements under which lines in different Alliances operate shared services.

    Competition authorities until now have relied on traditional but incomplete tools to assess the level of concentration across trades, most commonly the Herfindahl–Hirschman Index (HHI). However, this indicator does not take into consideration the full extent of co-operation between shipping lines permitted under block exemption and other anti-trust immunity provisions.

    When these ‘inter-Alliance’ consortia are included the concentration of the market, as measured by the modified HHI, is much higher. The Modified HHI exceeds the accepted threshold of 2,500 points at which an industry is considered ‘highly concentrated’, by most competition regulators. 

    GSF believes the recent ‘Fact Finding Investigation 29 - Final Report’ published by the US Federal Maritime Commission in May this year does not yet provide a complete picture, as the report maintains the liner trades serving the USA can be characterised as exhibiting ‘vigorous competition’ because their HHI has been measured at below 2,500 points.

    GSF urges the FMC and all other competition authorities to utilise the more accurate MHHI measure in its assessments of the container shipping market, and in particular of the concentration in market share achieved through all agreements permitted under block exemption and anti-trust immunity provisions.

    “This breakthrough analysis lays bare the degree of dominance that many shipping lines actually have in the key global trades,” comments GSF’s Director James Hookham. “Current measures of market concentration are only seeing part of the picture. Not only are there consortia operations within the three main Alliances, the number of separate consortia that exist consisting of lines from different Alliances is also significant.” 

    It is GSF’s contention that a lack of, or reduction in the levels of competition, leads directly to poor service quality for shippers. This is borne out by other findings in the ‘Quarterly Review’. The number of port calls achieved (in comparison with those scheduled) fell to 68%, the lowest level recorded since this analysis began in 2020 and, though capacity lost through skipped ports in Europe declined in Q1 2022, it continued to rise in both Asia and Australia with shippers consequently suffering from further export delays.




2022 October 6

19:30 Loading of General Chernyakhovsky ferry begins following flag-hoising ceremony
18:07 MSC updates Noumea Express service
17:29 Russian Maritime Register of Shipping issues statement on the EU Council press release of October 6, 2022
17:27 100-pct stock of Murmansk Sea Fish Port collected in favor of the state under action filed by FAS
17:12 EU adopts its latest package of sanctions against Russia
17:05 Three partners to join the North Field South development project
16:58 Nexans signs Empire Wind contract to bring renewable energy to New York
16:39 RF Government counts on having about 1,100 various ships built at domestic shipyards by 2030
16:38 JCB appoints Maersk as its new global Lead Logistics Provider
16:13 Port Houston orders 26 eco-efficient hybrid Konecranes RTGs
15:35 EST-Floattech signs contract for refit to hydrogen-electrical propulsion of 'FPS Maas' inland shipping barge
15:20 Cargo traffic on North-South ITC can double by 2030 – Mikhail Mishustin
14:58 KSOE wins orders for 7 vessels worth over KRW2tn - BusinessKorea
14:37 EU agrees on eighth package of sanctions against Russia
13:41 MABUX: Bunker Weekly Outlook, Week 40, 2022
13:19 Port of Gdansk handled over 7.6 million tonnes of coal year-to-date
12:55 Allseas to fit vessels with hybrid power solutions from Kongsberg Maritime
12:15 Russian ships can carry about 90 million tonnes of cargo per year
11:36 LR signs contract with Birdon for new Royal Australian Navy Sail Training Ship
11:08 First batch of coal shipped from Syradasayskoye field on Taimyr peninsula
10:34 AB Klaipėdos Nafta declares purchase option to acquire Independence
10:30 Oil production in Russia to decrease by 6-7% in 2023 - Alexander Novak
10:09 NYK and Group Company to introduce integrated shipping system as a DX Foundation
09:47 Wartsila and Capital Gas to partner in greenhouse gas reduction with Fleet Decarbonisation Programme
09:26 OPEC+ approved oil production cut by 2 million barrels a day
09:01 MABUX: In Global bunker market upward trend to continue on Oct 06
07:50 Crowley completes the purchase of 42 acres in Salem, Massachusetts, for the development of the state’s second major offshore wind port terminal

2022 October 5

18:37 Austal Australia to undertake patrol boat autonomy trial for Royal Australian Navy
18:06 Associated British Ports signs new agreement with the UK’s largest privately owned fertiliser importer
17:55 Initiation ceremony for cadets of Admiral Makarov State University of Maritime and Inland Shipping held in Kronstadt
17:36 Kongsberg Digital signs new partnership agreement with Alpha Ori Technologies
17:25 Unmanned electric passenger ships can appear in Saint-Petersburg
17:06 MSPs back Forth Green Freeport bid to deliver green growth plan for Scotland
16:52 DSME lands LNG carrier orders worth KRW1.85tn - BusinessKorea
16:08 GTT receives an order from Hyundai Heavy Industries for the tank design of seven LNG carriers
15:50 Container traffic on Russian Railways’ internal network in 9M’2022 rose by 3.6% YoY
15:36 WSC, ICS and ASA submit their input to the European Commission on the renewal of the CBER
15:27 Bunker sales at Vladivostok port in 9M’2022 fell by 28% YoY
15:04 Alfa Laval to be a technology partner for the project to investigate the on-board capture, storage and off-loading of carbon dioxide
14:41 IMO's GreenVoyage2050 celebrates five years of its Global Industry Alliance to Support Low Carbon Shipping
14:18 Marine passenger infrastructure of Saint-Petersburg should be converted to cater for inland water transport ‒ expert
14:12 ABS approves pioneering autonomous technology for HHI Group
13:54 NOREBO commences preparation works on construction of reefer terminal “Udarnik” in Murmansk Region
13:32 Pavilion Energy and MOL name newbuild LNG bunker vessel
13:02 General cargo ship bound for Russia disabled in Bosphorus - FleetMon
12:42 USC commences serial production of propulsion/steering units ДРК1200М
12:20 UK Government funds consortium led by Unitrove to deliver world’s first zero-emission multi-fuel station for hydrogen and electric ships
12:01 Finnlines to launch two new ro-pax vessels in autumn 2023
11:36 MOL signs LNG carrier charter contract for Sakhalin II project
11:29 Throughput of Azov port in 9M’2022 fell by 13% YoY to 6.8 million tonnes
11:21 Port of Rotterdam Authority presents future scenarios for 2050
11:01 Singapore sets out to drive transformation in bunkering on the world's largest forum for the marine fuel industry
10:39 A.P. Moller - Maersk orders six large ocean-going vessels that can sail on green methanol
10:20 Anemoi and COSCO Shipping Heavy Industry to offer full wind propulsion technology installation services
10:05 Shearwater GeoServices to introduce the geophysical company’s first dual ROV seismic vessel
09:39 MOL joins Blue Visby Consortium
09:28 Traffic volumes on Ust-Luga – Baltiysk ferry line are stable
08:52 MABUX: Upward changes to continue in Global bunker market on Oct 05

2022 October 4

18:43 Samskip adds Value Maritime CO2 capture to decarbonisation strategy
18:32 DEME upgrades DP fallpipe vessel fleet