• 2022 June 15 14:12

    Fuel consumption is a burning issue in the race for ship emissions compliance - Maritime Oslofjord Alliance

    Operational and technical measures are the most viable route to emissions abatement and compliance for the existing fleet of tankers, bulkers and containerships as many of these are unsuitable for low-carbon fuel conversions that can also pose commercial and other risks, according to a study, according to Blue-C's release.

    The fresh in-depth analysis, entitled Energy Transition in Shipping – Facts and Timeline, has assessed the commercial and technical viability of measures to cut emissions in the three ship sectors over the next three to five years.

    It has been carried out by the Maritime Oslofjord Alliance and funded by Oslo Maritime Foundation and Oslo Shipowners’ Association, in association with report author and editor Svein Helge Guldteig of Ocean Consulting AS.

    According to the study, the three segments of vessels above 5000 tonnes deadweight account for about 80% of the greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) from the world fleet of around 94,000 vessels. Some 19,000 vessels of more than 25,000 gross registered tons, or 21% of the global fleet, consume 65% of all fuel used in shipping.

    Resolving GHG emissions in the larger container, bulker and tanker segments will have an immediate and larger impact on the total emissions than any other shipping segment as they have the ships that consume the most fuel.

    The study also states that only around 15%, ie. 2700 tankers, bulkers and containerships, are outfitted with electronically controlled main engines that make them viable for conversion to alternative fuels, which could cut emissions by 100 million tonnes annually.

    Therefore, “most existing ships will have to find other applicable ways and means to reduce emissions based on tangible technical and operational measures”, states the report.

    Pressure is mounting on shipowners to take action to ensure compliance for their existing fleets with EEXI and CII requirements, effective on 1 January 2023, that are intended to meet the IMO´s initial goal to cut the carbon intensity of shipping by 40% within 2030 and halve emissions by 2050.

    These rules are set to become progressively tighter over time, with the IMO strategy due for revision next year, and are set to affect the commercial value of existing tonnage if not complied with.

    Furthermore, the industry faces the prospect of punitive carbon pricing for pollutive ships with the prospective inclusion of shipping in the EU´s Emissions Trading System next year under the so-called Fit for 55 package of measures aimed at cutting maritime emissions by 90% within 2050.

    However, meaningful cuts in emissions can be achieved in the near term by implementing relatively low-cost measures focused on reducing energy and fuel consumption, according to the report.

    It highlights slowing ship speed as “the most powerful way to cut emissions”, citing an estimated reduction of 50% in fuel consumption and emissions by reducing speed from 15 to 12 knots. A 10% reduction in speed for a typical merchant ship is estimated to cut emissions by 27%. Another operational measure to reduce emissions is using drop-in biofuels or e-fuels into the existing fuel.

    There are also technical steps that can deliver significant fuel efficiency gains including modification and optimisation of hull and propulsion equipment, as well as retuning the engine for lower loads at reduced speed.

    Report author Svein Helge Guldteig says “slow steaming has formerly been used sporadically over the past five decades to save fuel costs in periods with high fuel prices and adverse market conditions”.

    “In recent years slow steaming has been applied in many shipping segments, and reduction of emissions of existing ships beyond the current level will require even lower speed and/or other technical and operational measures applied in the future,” Guldteig explains.

    And he adds: “Digitalisation can now play an important role in supporting operational measures and realising potential savings from fuel optimisation that were not possible only a few years back.”

    Aside from a limited scope for retrofits, the report highlights drawbacks with fuel conversions related to cost, regulatory compliance, energy density and fuel tank space requirement that can negatively affect commercial operations.

    “Many existing ships will face technical and economical hurdles in the process of being converted to use alternative low or zero-carbon fuels - such as LNG and methanol - with a flashpoint below 60 degrees Celsius for which strict IGF regulations will apply,” Guldteig says.

    The report further states that “scarce availability of alternative fuels and most likely limited shipyard capacity will limit the readiness to adapt quickly for the large vessel shipping segment”, while there is also a lack of global shipyard capacity for the volume of conversions required in a 3-to-5-year perspective.

    Another long-term dilemma is whether there is worldwide shipbuilding capacity available to renew the entire shipping fleet within the time limit set by regulators for the global fleet emissions.

    Heavy investments will be needed to scale up global supply infrastructure for green and blue fuels, which is not expected to be in place until 2035-40 at the earliest, also challenged by the fact that existing LNG bunkering vessels sufficiently can supply only around 5% of the world fleet.

    This points to the quandary that the existing fleet using conventional fuel will still have to contribute significantly to reducing GHG emissions in the short and long term.

    A complete conversion on an existing vessel to alternative fuels, on the other hand, is in the range of $18–20m, and such an outlay has to be shared across the shipping value chain to compensate owners for front-loaded costs to incentivise investment in retrofits, according to the report. The relatively high cost of alternative fuels would also necessitate a carbon tax level of 200% to make such a fuel installation economically viable.

    However, a carbon tax would be an incentive to reduce the overall fuel consumption and thereby also the emissions.

    The report also stresses an overlooked item related to securing competent human resources and crew to operate vessels with more advanced control systems and procedures to maintain safe operation and handling of new onboard technology and bunkering systems. Such skillsets will be in demand and will take time to develop. The industry will need to collaborate to enable safe operation of vessels operating with net-zero emission technology, it states.

    There is no complete and final technology and infrastructure available to deliver on the industry’s mission to reduce GHG emissions within the timeline envisaged by regulators. While the industry waits for future solutions, optionality on types of fuel, design and infrastructure in the investment decisions by owners and operators are vital to minimize risk, according to the study.

    For existing ships there are limitations as to what can be done to reduce emissions in the short and medium-term perspective (3-5 years).

    Some 2,700 ships can be retrofitted to reduce emissions by 100m tonnes annually.

    There is only a limited amount of net-zero carbon emission available, and the technology, distribution and logistics for alternative fuels are scarce. The maturity of technology is in its early or infant stage.

    Reducing energy consumption by operational and technical measures is the most promising route to follow overall.
     
    The MARITIME OSLOFJORD ALLIANCE comprises:
     
    Ocean Industry Forum Oslofjord, chaired by Jon Rysst.
     
    Oslo Shipowners’ Association , chaired by Aage Thoen, shipowner.
     
    Shipping & Offshore Network, chaired by Per Olaf Brett.


2024 March 29

18:00 SLB announces agreement to acquire majority ownership in Aker Carbon Capture
17:14 “K” Line and Nippon Gas Line establish a marketing company to provide liquefied CO2 transportation services for carbon capture and storage projects
16:47 VTTI and IKAV enter agreement to purchase majority ownership of Adriatic LNG, Italy
16:25 Mitsubishi Shipbuilding receives order from the University of Tokyo for "MiPoLin" power prediction and lines selection system
15:41 Wan Hai Lines holds naming ceremony for 13,100TEU newbuilding “WAN HAI A15”
15:10 MOL announces restructuring measures
14:45 Drewry predicts impact on container calls at US East Coast ports after the collapse of the Francis Scott Key Bridge
14:25 Chevron’s first hybrid electric fueling barge arrives in Singapore
13:40 HD KSOE and Infineon sign MoU to develop ship electrification technology
13:29 NYK and JMU formulate method for evaluating ship performance in actual seas
12:59 HD Hyundai wins US$463 mln warship order in Peru
12:09 COSCO SHIPPING Ports throughput up by 4.4% YoY to 135,808,554 TEU in 2023
11:46 The "Ane Maersk" calls at the Eurogate container terminal in Hamburg for the first time on its maiden voyage from Asia to Europe
11:20 Sallaum Lines and Fujian Mawei Shipbuilding commence construction of Ocean Class vessels
10:43 Oasis Marine develops solutions for offshore hydrogen bunkering
10:03 Petrofac secures contract extension with ONEgas West in the UK market

2024 March 28

18:05 Jan De Nul, ENGIE and Equans launch a pilot project centred around the use of Vanadium Redox Flow batteries
17:35 Latvian port equipment manufacturer Bleste introduces new bulk handling ‘bucket’
17:05 Investors upgrade Navios Maritime Partners
16:25 DEME reports 22% increase in the orderbook and a record-high turnover of 3.3 billion euros in 2023
16:14 MABUX: Bunker Outlook, Week 13, 2024
15:41 AD Ports Group announced the opening of Saadiyat Marina & Ferry Terminal and Rabdan Marina
15:11 Sydney invests $11.5 million in two new operational vessels designed by Incat Crowther
14:55 China’s Jinzhao wins Peru $405m port construction contract
14:13 APM Terminals Moín handled six million TEU
13:48 ClassNK grants Innovation Endorsements for Products & Solutions to two innovative initiatives by MOL
13:37 Konecranes launches its flagship Konecranes X-series industrial crane
12:53 United European Car Carriers UECC spearheads collaboration with industry leaders to advance CNSL as a sustainable marine fuel
12:26 Ocean Network Express announces Transpacific service
11:48 Yang Ming announces 2025 Trans-Pacific service network
11:24 Fincantieri signs contract for the supply of two PPAs to Indonesia
10:42 Maersk transported more than 660,000 TEU using clean fuel in 2023
10:23 Documentation delays push industry costs to $3bn
09:48 PONANT and FARWIND Energy partner to develop green hydrogen refueling solutions

2024 March 27

18:22 Bureau Veritas awards world’s first prototype certification for SolarDuck’s floating offshore solar solution
17:58 The recently converted Allseas's shallow water pipelay barge starts preparations for its first commercial project
17:38 The Port of Rotterdam calls on the European Commission and Parliament to focus on actively promoting green energy
15:23 SEFE to become sole shareholder of WIGA
14:53 Ocean Installer secures yet another SLM contract with Equinor
14:23 Cadeler signs offshore wind turbine installation contract for the vessel Wind Scylla
13:42 Carnival Cruise Line orders 5th Excel-class cruise ship
13:11 Maersk and MSC overcharging cargo owners for EU ETS, says T&E
12:52 The Port Authority of Valencia launches the ZAL project in the Port of Valencia
12:11 Clarkson Port Services and Peak Group collaborate to deliver Port Agency services across the North Sea
11:42 Wan Hai Lines holds ship naming ceremony for new vessels
11:24 Consolidated shipping lines EBIT loss was $1.44 billion in Q4 2023: Sea-Intelligence
10:49 Seaspan Shipyards receives long-term contracts for the pre-construction work of the the Canadian Coast Guard's first six multi-mission vessels
10:14 Woodside completes sale of 10% scarborough interest

2024 March 26

18:02 COSCO Shipping Lines introduces new Americas service
17:30 Davie awarded first contract for design of icebreaker fleet under Canada’s National Shipbuilding Strategy
17:04 Sanctions complicate Arctic LNG ship sales, Hanwha Ocean says - Bloomberg
16:57 Terntank places an order for 1+1 additional wind/ methanol-ready hybrid tanker
16:28 BW LNG completes acquisition of two TFDE vessels from Stena Bulk
15:50 Hanwha Ocean develops VR-based special vehicle simulator
15:20 TotalEnergies and SINOPEC join forces to produce sustainable jet fuel at a SINOPEC's refinery
14:52 Wärtsilä Lifecycle Agreement to guarantee operational reliability of new wind farm installation vessel
14:23 Hudong-Zhonghua launches two LNG carriers
13:51 Cargo ship hits Baltimore’s Key Bridge
13:12 Final sanctioned tanker with Russian Sokol oil to reach China port - Reuters
12:42 Adani Ports acquires 95% of Odisha's Gopalpur Port from SP Group for $162 million
12:21 IHI and Yara Clean Ammonia agree to jointly assess clean ammonia business collaboration
11:41 Yara Clean Ammonia and Azane granted safety permit to build world's first low emission ammonia bunkering terminal
11:16 Wartsila and Royal Caribbean Group celebrate 15 years of collaboration on digital transformation
10:46 A global carbon tax on shipping is coming, says ABS Chairman and CEO
10:21 Eni, Fincantieri and RINA establish partnership for maritime transport decarbonization

2024 March 25

18:07 The Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore continues to investigate reports of oil spills off the port of Tuas
17:31 “K” Line, NIPPON HAKUYO and OPT Gate sign an agreement for a new fire detection system for car carriers
17:07 Greek merchant fleet recorded slight decline in January 2024
16:47 Hanwha Ocean Plans to develop green technology and naval ships
16:25 U-Ming Singapore and ITOCHU sign milestone MoU for the joint development of ammonia dual-fuel and de-carbonized vessels